Don’t listen to New Yorkers — there really is good pizza to be found in Orlando! I grew up in Miami eating three kinds of pizza:
- New York-style pizza — large, crispy, thin, foldable slices with melty, elastic cheese, dripping orange grease.
- Sicilian pizza — thick rectangular slices with crispy crust and bottom, and soft, fluffy interior.
- School lunch pizza (always on Thursday) — also rectangular, but flat and crispy like a flatbread, and the cheese could usually be peeled off in one solid sheet. This was not good pizza by any standard, but we loved it as kids, and I still associate Thursdays with “PIZZA FOR LUNCH! PIZZA FOR LUNCH!” chants.
But anyway, to this day, my two go-to pizza styles are New York-style and Sicilian. Even though I like other kinds — Neapolitan pies, coal oven pizza, even St. Louis-style pizza, crackery-thin with gooey Provel cheese — those two are my lifelong favorites, and there are plenty of good pizzerias around Orlando to get New York-style pizza. I’ve already reviewed several of them, but a few of those, like Pizzeria Del Dio and Paradiso Restaurant and Pizzeria, also offer the harder-to-find rectangular Sicilian pizzas. I’m happy to report that one more pizzeria offers both styles, with two convenient locations on opposite ends of Winter Park: Antonella’s Pizzeria (https://www.antonellaspizza.com/).
Antonella’s original location is on Fairbanks Avenue, between New York and Pennsylvania Avenues, right near Rollins College and tony Park Avenue. I ate there once, many years ago, but I can’t find the photos I took of that quick lunch (a slice of pizza and an Italian sub), although I’m sure they were awful photos. The newest location that opened earlier this year is much closer to my work, on University Avenue, just east of Goldenrod Road. It’s a small, modern, cozy space, and I look forward to lingering there for more leisurely work lunches in the months to come.
Here is Antonella’s lunch menu, which is not listed on the website with the regular menu.
On my first visit to the new location, I ordered takeout for myself and my work “lunch bunch,” starting us out with a half-dozen garlic knots ($5.95). These were darker than I like, but they had plenty of garlic, butter, parmesan, and herbs to add rich, pungent flavors. They also came with a dipping cup of marinara sauce, as all garlic rolls should.
I always have to try a plain slice at any New York-style pizzeria to use as a benchmark and a “control.” This slice was $3, and it was outstanding, just as it was on my first trip to Antonella’s older location a few years ago. Nice and crispy, large enough to fold, tangy red sauce with the slightest sweetness, and the cheese had a good “pull” to it.
Another co-worker and I each enjoyed a slice of Sicilian pizza topped with pepperoni ($4.50 each,or $4 without the single topping). This is definitely some of the best Sicilian pizza in Orlando. The rectangular slices are aren’t as wide as Del Dio or Paradiso, but they are long and thick. (BWAH HA HA!)
One co-worker asked for a slice of pizza bianca (mozzarella and ricotta cheese with no red sauce; $3.75) and a plain Sicilian slice ($4). She seemed to love them.
Meatballs are another one of my Italian restaurant benchmarks, so I had to try Antonella’s version (a side of two meatballs, cut in half so it looked like I got four, for $5.95). They were very soft, tender, yielding, flavorful, and I got much more of that good sauce to dip my crusts in.
On a second trip, I brought some takeout home so my wife could try Antonella’s food. I got another slice of pizza for myself and more garlic knots for us to share. I also got one of her go-to Italian dishes, eggplant rollatini ($15.95). This thin-sliced eggplant dish is rolled up with ricotta cheese, then breaded, fried, topped with red sauce and mozzarella cheese, then baked to melt the cheese. She prefers it really light on the sauce, and they did it her way:
It came with a choice of pasta, plus soup or salad. She told me to choose, and I went with the pasta e fagioli soup of the day, good old “pasta fa-ZHOOL” with ditalini pasta, white beans, onions, carrots, celery, and herbs in chicken broth with little bits of chicken. It was delicious!
One of our favorite Orlando Italian restaurants of times past was Wolfie’s PizzaMia on Orange Avenue. We loved it with all our hearts, and our hearts ached when it closed. Since then, Chef A.J. Haines has found a new home making Southern comfort food and occasional fresh pasta dishes at Mason Jar Provisions, but at Wolfie’s, he introduced us to the wonders of arancini, a ball of risotto stuffed with meat, rolled in bread crumbs, and fried until the outer surface is crispy, the rice inside is soft and almost creamy, and the seasoned ground beef in the center is warm and welcoming. Antonella’s version of arancini ($4.95), served with a side of that robust red sauce, did not disappoint.
It reminds me a lot of my beloved Cuban papas rellenas, but instead of a baseball-sized ball of mashed potatoes stuffed with picadillo, you have the creamy risotto in arancini. Also, there were peas in with the seasoned meat, unlike the picadillo in a papa rellena (which sometimes includes olives).
Finally, anyone who knows me or reads this blog knows how my absolute favorite things to eat are cured deli meats, especially when assembled in an Italian sub. I had to try the Antonella’s Combo hero ($10.95), with ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and house dressing on a soft sub roll, served cold (although you could get it hot too).
It tasted good, because of course it did, but there are bigger and better Italian subs elsewhere in the city, and I have sung their praises often: LaSpada’s, Manzano’s, Stasio’s (which occasionally serves huge and awesome square slices of Sicilian pizza), and Tornatore’s (which also boasts excellent New York-style pizza). I would have liked a better meat-to-bread ratio in this hero sandwich. I’m not sorry I tried it, but next time I’ll stick to Antonella’s wondrous pizza, which is definitely some of the best in Orlando. Come in and try it for yourself, and I’m sure you will agree. I hope even transplanted New Yorkers will be pleasantly surprised.